Man killed on East Third was repeat offender

Published: Thursday, March 14, 2013 @ 4:27 AM
Updated: Thursday, March 14, 2013 @ 2:07 PM

A man who was shot and killed on East Third Street early Thursday morning had an extensive history of run-ins with police in that part of town.

Police said Michael E. Neibert, 41, was killed around 2 a.m. at a duplex at 3723 E. Third.

According to family members, Neibert was visiting his mother who lives on one side of the duplex and went over to the other half where some sort of argument ensued with the two people inside.

Police radio traffic indicated that one of the men inside the duplex called 911 at about 1:58 a.m. and said someone had broken a window and his friend had fired shots through the back door. When police arrived to investigate they discovered Neibert lying shot between two houses. They called for an ambulance at 2:09 a.m.

Neibert’s friends and family said he was sometimes hostile and was possibly arguing with the men about a TV that was stolen from one of them earlier in the evening.

“He just gets loud and wants to argue. He would have walked away,” said friend Darrell Hall. “It wasn’t nothing for them to have to shoot him for.”

Ciara Goff said her stepfather, who went by Mikey, has lived down the street and was well known in the neighborhood. “Everybody knows Mikey, they know how he is,” she said.

Police have not confirmed any details of the crime other than that there were two people inside the residence when Neibert was shot and they are questioning multiple people with knowledge of the incident.

Police are looking at the possibility that Neibert broke into the home Wednesday evening and returned early Thursday. Radio traffic indicates that police were at the address Wednesday at about 9:30 p.m. to take a burglary report.

Neibert’s criminal record includes 35 criminal arrests since 1992, according to Dayton Municipal Court records. Offenses he was accused of included domestic violence, assault and disorderly conduct. He had felony convictions for violating a protection order, theft and robbery.

Fairborn coach under investigation calls process ‘appalling’

Published: Monday, February 20, 2017 @ 11:59 AM
Updated: Monday, February 20, 2017 @ 4:13 PM

A Fairborn church pastor and school basketball coach publicly expressed frustration Monday that a Children Services investigation into him is still ongoing after more than six weeks.

Aaron Chivington serves as lead pastor of Fairborn United Methodist Church, and is a part-time middle school basketball coach with Fairborn City Schools. On Facebook Monday, he claimed that he had been falsely accused, saying the Children Services process was “appalling.”

>> FIRST STORY: Fairborn coach, pastor placed on leave

Chivington said publicly when the investigation began that Children Services removed seven foster children from the home he still shares with his wife and their biological children. Last week, in a Facebook live Q&A, he discussed his anger over that move and the fact that the children have not been returned. He remains active in his church role.

Greene County Children Services officials did not return calls in early January when Chivington was placed on leave, and their offices were closed Monday.

Fairborn City Schools Superintendent Mark North said Friday that Chivington will remain on administrative leave until the investigation is completed.

“We have not received an update or a final report on the investigation from Children Services,” North said Friday.

North said the investigation was sparked by complaints from a parent, and the school district investigated in late December. North said based on the schools’ own probe, and initial word from Children Services, they allowed Chivington to keep coaching through the Jan. 4 game.

But North said Children Services then sent a second communication notifying the school district that they would investigate the complaint. At that point on Jan. 5, Chivington was placed on leave by the schools.

Former Bengal arrested for assault, public indecency

Published: Monday, February 20, 2017 @ 4:15 PM

Former Bengal arrested for assault, public indecency

A former University of Cincinnati and Cincinnati Bengals player is in the Butler County jail facing several charges for an incident Sunday.

Jerome Kyle “J.K.” Schaffer, 26, was taken into about 10:15 a.m. at a church in Chapel Road in Morgan Twp., according to the sheriff’s office. He is charged with assault, breaking and entering and public indecency, according to jail records.

Deputies were called out to the 3400 block of Chapel after Schaffer allegedly assaulted a man then fled, according to the sheriff’ office. They then got a call from a church where Schaffer was allegedly trying to break into a car and was taking his clothes off.

Schaffer was arrested without incident, but when he was taken to the jail, “he uncooperative and in a very agitated state and appeared to be under the influence of some type of drug,” said Chief Deputy Anthony Dwyer.

On Monday, Schaffer remained housed in the jail. His case will be heard in Butler County Area I Court in Oxford, but a court date has not yet been set.

Schaffer played football for La Salle High School and UC. He signed on as an undrafted free agent with the Jacksonville Jaguars in 2012, but was released from the practice squad; he was picked up by the Bengals and signed to the practice squad that November. He was added to the roster in Sept. 2013, then waived in Aug. 2014, according to WCPO, our media partners.

Deputy accused in domestic violence case now on unpaid leave

Published: Friday, February 17, 2017 @ 12:46 PM
Updated: Friday, February 17, 2017 @ 9:42 PM

UPDATE @ 5:25 p.m. (Feb. 17): Sheriff's Deputy Douglas Gearhart is now on unpaid administrative leave, according to a letter from the Montgomery County Sheriff’s office personnel director. 

Gearhart, in the letter dated Feb. 16, is required to surrender his weapon, ID credentials, badge, keys and entry card. He also is prohibited from accessing the sheriff's office computer systems and programs. 

As of Friday afternoon, he was still in custody in the Warren County Jail. NEW: As of 8:03 p.m., Gearhart was no longer listed as a jail inmate, indicating he has posted bond and has been released.


A Montgomery County Sheriff’s deputy accused of assaulting his wife and stepdaughter earlier this week in Franklin Twp. was expected to be free on bond Friday.

Deputy Douglas C. Gearhart, 43, was allegedly intoxicated Tuesday evening when he fought with his step-daughters and wife, who lost three teeth during the incident.

Gearhart was arrested by Warren County Sheriff’s deputies and charged with two counts of domestic violence.

A charge of felonious assault was added later. He also is expected to face a drunk driving charge.

Judge Rupert Ruppert set bond at $35,000 cash or surety and Gearhart was expected to be released this afternoon.

He was being held in the Warren County Jail without bond, pending today’s hearing in Franklin Municipal Court.

RELATED: Officer cleared for alleged beating of homeless vet.

During the hearing, Ruppert also ordered Gearhart not to erase home surveillance video.

If released, Gearhart is expected to live with his parents. He is barred from contact with the alleged victims and be on a GPS monitor.

RELATED: Man assaults deputy during traffic stop, flees after pursuit.

Lawyer Ed Perry sought a low bond, noting Gearhart’s ties with the area.

Born and raised in West Carrollton, Gearhart first worked as a police officer in Middletown from 1996 to 2001, when he joined the Montgomery County Sheriff’s Office, according to Perry.

A police incident report said surveillance footage from inside Gearhart’s Franklin Twp. home showed him grabbing his wife, dragging her by the hair through the kitchen and slamming her head onto the edge of the kitchen island.

RELATED: Domestic violence victims may get tool to hide public records

The report also said 911 calls from Gearhart’s residence indicated that Gearhart returned home intoxicated and “was hitting everyone in the house.”

“Our step-dad is beating our mom right now,” one 911 caller told a dispatcher at about 6:40 p.m. “Oh my gosh, I knew this was going to happen.”

A preliminary hearing was scheduled for next Friday in the Franklin court, although Gearhart could be indicted before that in Warren County Common Pleas Court in Lebanon.

California officer killed by gang member while responding to traffic accident, police say

Published: Monday, February 20, 2017 @ 3:44 PM
Updated: Monday, February 20, 2017 @ 3:44 PM

            California officer killed by gang member while responding to traffic accident, police say

Two police officers who responded to a report of a traffic accident in California on Monday morning were shot, one fatally, and a known gang member was injured, according to authorities.

>> Read more trending stories

The gang member, who was not identified, was injured after he shot a semi-automatic gun at Whittier police officers and they returned fire, The Los Angeles Times reported.

The shooting was reported around 8 a.m. after authorities were called to a three-car collision, the Whittier Daily News reported. The shooting happened near the intersection of Mar Vista Street and Colima Road, deputies said.

Los Angeles County sheriff's Lt. John Corina told reporters that the gunman was driving a stolen vehicle when he collided with two other vehicles on Colima Road. Authorities said the man opened fire on officers as they were approaching the scene of the crash.

The officers returned fire and struck the man at least once, deputies said.

Emergency officials took the injured police officers and the injured gunman to a pair of hospitals for treatment, where one of the officers died, the Daily News reported. Police did not immediately identify the slain officer or any of the other people involved in the incident.

"It's extremely tragic," Corina told The Associated Press. "You just never know when officers respond to a call what they are going to run into."

Both the gunman and the wounded officer were in stable condition Monday afternoon, the Times reported. The other people involved in the accident that sparked police response were not injured, according to the AP.

About 130 sworn officers make up the force of the Whittier Police Department, according to the Times. The department is tasked with policing Whittier and Santa Fe Springs in southeastern Los Angeles County.