2 indicted on murder charges in separate Springfield deaths

Published: Monday, November 28, 2016 @ 6:46 PM


            Tevius Turner
            Clark County Jail records
Tevius Turner(Clark County Jail records)

A Clark County grand jury approved charges Monday against two men in connection with separate murder cases.

Nicholas Starling, 16, has been indicted on a charges of aggravated murder, three charges of murder and two charges of tampering with evidence in connection with the Oct. 30 beating and stabbing death of his 14-year-old brother.

RELATED: Springfield teen charged in brother’s death to be tried as adult

Harley Starling was found dead in the boys’ Superior Avenue home. Nicholas was arrested hours after police began their investigation, Clark County Prosecutor Andy Wilson said, and evidence points that the older brother allegedly beat the teen with a baseball bat and then stabbed him.

Last week a Clark County Juvenile Court approved moving the case to adult court, where Nicholas Starling could face life in prison without parole, Wilson said.

Nicholas Starling is booked in the Clark County Jail on a $100,000 bond, according to court records.

Tevius Turner, 35, has been indicted on charges related to the shooting death on Nov. 18 of 29-year-old Melody Turner, of Springfield.

DETAILS: $1M bond on murder charge for Springfield shooting suspect

A Clark County grand jury approved charges Monday of aggravated murder, murder, felony murder, felonious assault, tampering with evidence and improper handling firearms in a motor vehicle in the case, according to court records.

Police alleged that Tevius Turner shot Melody Turner while she was in a car with another man. The passenger was the intended target, police have said.

Tevius Turner was arrested in Kentucky and is booked in the Clark County Jail on a $1 million bond. He could face life in prison without parole if he’s found guilty in the case.

Both men are scheduled to appear in a Clark County Common Pleas court to be arraigned on the new charges later this week.

Clark County Prosecutor Andy Wilson reports that the Grand Jury met Monday and also returned the following indictments:

Cathy Caroppoli, 52, 5580 W. Parkwood Ave.: Breaking and entering

Benjamin Buck, 36, 735 Linden Ave.: Failure to comply with order or signal of a police officer.

Paul Edward Terrell, 64, 1007 Oak St.: Improper handling of firearms in a motor vehicle.

Carl Poole, 58, 1014 S. Burnett Road: Domestic violence.

Justin Joseph Biles, 30: Felonious assault.

Carl Walker, 30: Felonious assault.

Police: Man, 18 shot another in chest; charges dropped against juvenile

Published: Wednesday, January 17, 2018 @ 9:30 AM
Updated: Wednesday, January 17, 2018 @ 6:00 PM

CLARK COUNTY JAIL
CLARK COUNTY JAIL

UPDATE @ 6 p.m.

Charges have been dropped against a juvenile, but an 18-year-old Springfield resident remains accused of shooting a man in the chest last week.

Elrashawn T. Dover, pleaded not guilty during his arraignment Sunday in Clark County Municipal Court. His bond was set at $250,000 and a public defender was appointed. He also was ordered to have no contact with the victim, should he post bail.

>> Springfield woman accused of hitting 6-year-old in head with belt

The victim was stepping out of his car shortly after 2 p.m. Jan. 8 in the 300 block of West Grand Avenue in Springfield. He told police he heard gunfire and then felt a gunshot to his chest, according to court documents. 

"He said he grabbed his chest and could see blood on his hand," police say in court records. 

The victim's brother then drove him to the Springfield Regional Medical Center, where he was treated for a gunshot wound to the right side of his chest and was expected to recover, police said. 

>> South Charleston boy, 8, dies in possible bathtub drowning

Court records showed the victim identified Dover as the shooter after reviewing a photo lineup.

Dover already was in the Clark County Jail on several unrelated charges.

Springfield police also arrested last week a male juvenile who a witness identified as involved in the shooting and booked him into juvenile detention on an attempted murder charge, according to court records. 

Clark County prosecutors requested to dismiss the charges against the teen, which the juvenile judge granted. 

"Right now everything is looking and pointing toward (Dover) and we dismissed at this point to give us more time to make sure whether the juvenile is involved or not," Clark County Assistant Prosecutor Bill Merrell said. "We don't know that yet."

FIRST REPORT

Two people, including a juvenile, were arrested and charged with attempted murder in connection to a Jan. 8 shooting on West Grand Avenue in Springfield.

The victim was stepping out of his car in the 300 block of West Grand and heard gunshots and then felt a gunshot to his chest, court documents read.

LOCAL NEWS: Dayton school bus with kids inside involved in crash

Last Friday, the victim identified Elrashawn T. Dover, 18, as the person who shot him after reviewing a photo lineup, court records showed.

Police arrested the juvenile the day after the shooting and booked him into juvenile detention.

Dover already was in the Clark County Jail on unrelated charges.

‘Bad timing. Real bad.’: Men seen illegally entering building with K-9 training happening nearby

Published: Wednesday, January 17, 2018 @ 3:51 PM

Police chief saw them breaking into closed hotel

When the Middletown police chief and two new City Council were having lunch Wednesday on the fourth floor of the City Building, they noticed through a window that it appeared two subjects were climbing a fire escape and entering a window on the upper floors of the former Manchester Inn.

So Chief Rodney Muterspaw, who was meeting with council members Joe Mulligan and Ami Vitori, called police dispatch to report the suspicious activity at the hotel that closed seven years ago.

MORE TRENDING NEWS

» Mike Fox’s ‘simple’ choice: ‘I either lose this weight or I lose my life’

» Why did standoff suspect surrender? Police were ‘driving him crazy’

As the two suspects were illegally trying to enter the Manchester Inn, the police department’s K-9 team was training along with eight agencies of the Southwest Regional K-9 Training Team at the city’s K-9 training center near the Middletown Regional Airport.

“Bad timing,” Muterspaw said with a laugh. “Real bad.”

Middletown’s K-9 officers Bear, Chase and Koda, along with dogs from the other police agencies, entered the building, said Officer Ryan Morgan, Chase’s handler. Morgan said there were 11 dogs stationed in and around the Manchester Inn.

“Dogs were barking everywhere,” Morgan said.

While Morgan and Chase were on the second floor, Chase, a 4-year-old German shepherd, indicted he smelled human scent, Morgan said. When they found the subjects hiding in a hotel room, Chase “showed force” and the subjects quickly surrendered, Morgan said.

Morgan said there is “no better training than real life scenarios.”

Nicholas Tsakeris, 18, and a juvenile were charged with criminal trespass, police said.

This story will be updated.

Springboro teacher’s criminal case headed back to trial

Published: Wednesday, January 17, 2018 @ 2:45 PM

Springboro teacher’s criminal case headed back to trial

A judge today denied a Springboro teacher facing criminal charges in a drug case also involving her son treatment in lieu of conviction during a hearing in Warren County Common Pleas Court.

Amy Panzeca, 48, of Springboro, is facing charges of permitting drug abuse, contributing to the unruliness of a minor and endangering children in Warren County Common Pleas Court.

Judge Donald Oda II denied the motion for lack of evidence that Panzeca’s alleged drinking problem contributed to her permitting drug abuse in her home.

RELATED: Personnel file indicates teacher in drug case among ‘most admired and respected’ in Springboro 

The case stems from traffic stops last year by Springboro police and a raid last May by the Warren County Drug Task Force of the Panzeca home in the Settlers Walk community in Springboro.

Springboro teacher Amy Panzeca after her motion for treatment in lieu of convicion was denied by Judge Donald Oda II. LAWRENCE BUDD/STAFF(Staff Writer)

In December, her son, now 16, was sentenced to 30 more days in the local detention center as part of his sentence in Warren County Juvenile Court after pleading no contest to charges of trafficking in drugs and possession of controlled substances.

He got credit for 15 days already spent in detention, but was ordered to complete an in-patient treatment program.

RELATED: Teen sentenced in drug case also involving teacher, a Springboro teacher

Panzeca is accused of converting her son’s money, including a birthday gift, to Bitcoin, which he used to buy LSD, some of which he sold to about 20 Springboro students.

RELATED: Lawyers, judge huddle on Springboro teacher’s drug case

In December, Oda found an oral motion by Panzeca’s lawyer “to be well-taken, in part” and ordered the long-time teacher be examined.

Her lawyer, Andrea Ostrowski, filed a motion that said: “Drug or alcohol usage by the defendant was a factor leading to the instant offense.”

MORE: Another strip club raid defendant granted intervention

Offenders granted treatment in lieu of conviction must abstain from drugs and alcohol for 12 months, take part in treatment programs and submit to random testing in order to complete the diversion program. It also can include community service and financial restitution.

MORE: Lawyer, radio analyst accepted into treatment program

If offenders complete the program, the court dismisses the original charges and can potentially seal the records related to the case.

Since August, Panzeca has been free on her own recognizance, pending trial. She had been pressing for the identity of confidential informants in the case and suppression of statements made to police.

Oda delayed all other proceedings in the case, pending outcome of todays’s hearing. A suppression hearing is to be scheduled next in the case.

Trial date scheduled for alleged Trotwood shooter

Published: Wednesday, January 17, 2018 @ 3:03 PM

The defendant who allegedly shot at police officers in Trotwood had his trial scheduled for March 5.

The trial for alleged Trotwood “active shooter” Willam D. Gibson has been tentatively scheduled for March 5.

Gibson, 42, faces 10 counts of felonious assault on peace officers and 11 other counts for allegedly firing at police after calling 911 on Oct. 13, 2017 to say his wife accidentally shot herself.

RELATED: Alleged Trotwood shooter’s cruiser statements will be allowed in court

Montgomery County Common Pleas Court Judge Dennis Adkins scheduled the trial date during his Wednesday docket. Attorneys indicated the date could be continued due to plea negotiations.

Adkins ruled during a Jan. 11 hearing that unrecorded statements Gibson allegedly made in the back of a cruiser would be allowed at trial.

RELATED: Man accused at shooting at Trotwood officers withdraws insanity plea

Gibson was transported to Montgomery County Jail after a standoff with police after his 911 call in which he said his wife accidentally shot herself in the leg. Gibson had not been given Miranda warnings when he was placed in a Trotwood cruiser.

That’s when Gibson allegedly said, “‘I probably shouldn’t have shot my wife, should I?” according to Trotwood police officer Bethany Morrissette, who testified during the Jan. 11 suppression hearing.

RELATED: Man accused of firing shots at Trotwood officers indicted

“After that, I said, ‘No, you probably shouldn’t have,’ ” Morrissette added. “And I believe I said, ‘You probably shouldn’t have shot at us, either.’ “

Morrissette told assistant Montgomery County prosecutor Meagan Woodall that there is no recording of Gibson’s or her comments after the incident that drew several law enforcement agencies and multiple SWAT teams to Wolf Creek Pike for 2½ hours.

RELATED: Trotwood active shooter standoff ends peacefully after 2½ hours

On cross examination, Morrissette told public defender Michael Pentecost that Gibson also said: “I just want to go see a judge tomorrow and plead guilty. I don’t want to spend any time in Montgomery County (Jail), I hate Montgomery County. I know I’m going to prison for a long time.”

MORE: Read other stories from Mark Gokavi

SOCIAL MEDIA: Follow Mark Gokavi on Twitter or Facebook